Posts
What happens when a careers website tells the truth
See other posts from by Bryan Adams
CEO
A few years ago, a Virgin Media engineer finished a job at the home of a pensioner who was facing Christmas alone.
Her television was broken, and for someone in her situation, that television was company, routine and a voice in the quiet. There was no protocol for what happened next. The engineer went out, bought her a new one with his own money and set it up before he left.
Now imagine you are hiring engineers, and you want people with that kind of empathy. The standard move is to ask candidates whether they are good with people, which invites the same rehearsed answer from everyone who has ever sat in an interview. Virgin Media did something smarter. They told the story instead, and even filmed a recreation of it, so that every candidate instantly understood the kind of care this company hires for. Nobody needed the values slide explained to them. The story did the explaining, and the people who recognized themselves in it leaned in.
That is the entire argument for truth on a careers website, compressed into one broken television. So why do most careers websites still read like they were written to survive a legal review rather than to be believed?
The wallpaper problem
Visit almost any careers website today and you will find the same site wearing different logos. The culture is collaborative, the people are passionate, the mission is bold and every photograph glows. None of it is a lie exactly, and that is what makes it so useless. It has been softened and generalized until it could describe any business in any industry, and candidates have learned to scroll straight past it the way homeowners stop seeing their own wallpaper.
Here is the uncomfortable part. Candidates are not naive, and they arrive with real questions. What is hard about this job? Will I belong here? Does the work matter? When your careers website declines to answer, they do not stop asking, they simply go and get their answers from Glassdoor, Reddit and a friend of a friend who used to work for you. The real scoop is already in circulation, told without your context, your care or your side of the story. The only real choice you have is whether the truth reaches candidates with you or without you.
Truth converts, gloss just gets traffic
A global technology company I worked with had a problem that will sound familiar. Their careers website looked good, ticked every functional box and pulled in serious traffic, yet it underperformed where it mattered most. High traffic. Low conversion. Great brand. Thin belief. They were telling the same polished, positive, forgettable story on every page.
So, the rebuild started with truth rather than design. The homepage stopped reciting adjectives and opened with the honest reason the company exists and the problems it is wrestling with. The team pages told stories of what it takes to thrive in engineering, sales, product and operations, including what the work feels like on the hard days as well as the good ones. The job pages acknowledged what would stretch someone in the role, then showed what they could earn on the other side in capability, growth and pride. In short, the site stopped selling perks and started selling truth.
Within six months, apply-click conversion increased, drop-off between viewing a role and applying reduced and the quality of candidates narrowed toward people genuinely aligned with the reality of the culture. Nothing magical happened. The truth simply started doing what truth does, which is filter. The people who would have struggled quietly opted out before anyone spent a penny interviewing them, and the people built for the environment arrived already believing. I have spent two decades arguing that an employer brand is a two-sided deal, a give and a get, what you offer set honestly beside what it takes, and a careers site is the single best place to put that deal in writing.
The stories are inside the building, the questions unlock them
Every organization already owns a library of Virgin Media moments. The reason you have never read them on a careers site is that nobody asked, or worse, somebody asked badly. Send employees a request for a testimonial and you will harvest beige. People assume the truth is off-limits at work, so they hand you the corporate version of themselves and wait for the edit.
The shift is to give people explicit license to tell the truth, then ask questions that deserve honest answers. Ask a new joiner what surprised them in week one, before the surprise fades into normality. Ask someone what they thought they could not do here until they surprised themselves. Ask what moment made them feel truly seen, which mistake shaped them most, or the question that reliably produces gold, whether they ever nearly quit and what stopped them. Questions like these signal that you want the real story, wobble included, and the wobble is precisely what makes the payoff believable. A story about someone who was stretched, doubted themselves and came through says more about your culture than any number of collaborative-passionate paragraphs, because struggle is the ingredient that turns a claim into a story worth telling.
Listen to what comes back and you will notice the same three currents underneath, a sense of purpose, a sense of impact and a sense of belonging. These are the things people want from work, and they are the things candidates are silently shopping for. Your employees will articulate them more convincingly than any copywriter, if you ask well and get out of the way.
Put the truth on camera
Once you have real stories, resist the urge to flatten them back into text. Candidates trust your employees roughly three times more than they trust your corporate messaging, and the format that carries an employee's credibility best is video, where tone, hesitation and pride survive intact. The numbers back this up. Job postings with video earn 12% more views and a 34% higher application rate, and many candidates say video is more engaging than text when they are weighing up an employer. One story told to camera by the person who lived it, imperfect lighting and all, will out convert a showreel, because candidates are fluent in the difference between produced and real.
Answer the questions they are afraid to ask
Then go one step further and answer the questions candidates never expect a careers website to touch.
-
What is the hardest part of this job?
-
What kind of person does not work out here?
-
What does the first year really feel like?
Answering these openly does something subtle and powerful, since every hard truth you volunteer makes your attractive claims more believable. A promise with a price attached reads as a deal, and people trust deals. Candidates are so unused to finding straight answers on a careers website that meeting them is a differentiator all by itself, and it is respect made visible. The right people do not want the brochure, they want to walk in with their eyes wide open, and the gratitude of someone who was told the truth upfront shows up later as engagement, resilience and loyalty.
What changes
Expect three things to happen when your careers website starts telling the truth.
-
Application quality rises even where volume dips, and the dip is your filter working.
-
New hires stop being surprised, so the resignations that begin with "it wasn't what I expected" begin to disappear, taking a quiet fortune in attrition costs with them.
-
And your employees start recognizing their employer in its own website, which turns them into willing storytellers rather than reluctant testimonial-givers, feeding the engine that keeps the site alive.
The truth about working at your company is already being told somewhere, in exit interviews, on review sites and across kitchen tables you will never sit at. The only decision you really get to make is whether your careers website tells it first and tells it better. The companies brave enough to do that convert strangers into believers before a single interview hour is spent, and they discover what Virgin Media discovered with one broken television, that the truth told well was never the risk. It was the advantage all along.
